Talk:Rogers 2011 PLoS One: Difference between revisions
From Bioblast
(Created page with " ==Comments by Erich Gnaiger== This paper describes application of a strongly advertised multi-well system (XF) for respirometry with isolated mitochondria. Where...") |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Comments by [[Gnaiger E|Erich Gnaiger]]== | |||
This paper describes application of a strongly advertised multi-well system (XF, 'Seahorse Bioscience') for respirometry with isolated mitochondria. Whereas multi-well systems do provide high throughput, it must be critically assessed if this is equivalent to high output of useful data and information. Based on expertise in [[high-resolution respirometry]] and [[mitochondrial physiology]], the paper by Rogers et al (2011) is discussed. | |||
Conflicts of interest: | |||
* Rogers GW and Ferrick DA are employees of Seahorse Bioscience (at the time of publication). | |||
* [[Gnaiger E]] is founder and director of [http://www.oroboros.at/index.php?o2k-team OROBOROS INSTRUMENTS]. | |||
===Instrumental specifications of the XF multi-well system are missing=== | ===Instrumental specifications of the XF multi-well system are missing=== | ||
| Line 8: | Line 12: | ||
===Comparison with low-resolution instruments=== | ===Comparison with low-resolution instruments=== | ||
Low-resolution instruments (compare [[HRR]] with Clark-type polarographic oxygen sensors were used | Low-resolution instruments (compare [[HRR]]) with Clark-type polarographic oxygen sensors were used for validation of data obtained with the XF. | ||
Revision as of 16:33, 24 September 2011
Comments by Erich Gnaiger
This paper describes application of a strongly advertised multi-well system (XF, 'Seahorse Bioscience') for respirometry with isolated mitochondria. Whereas multi-well systems do provide high throughput, it must be critically assessed if this is equivalent to high output of useful data and information. Based on expertise in high-resolution respirometry and mitochondrial physiology, the paper by Rogers et al (2011) is discussed.
Conflicts of interest:
- Rogers GW and Ferrick DA are employees of Seahorse Bioscience (at the time of publication).
- Gnaiger E is founder and director of OROBOROS INSTRUMENTS.
Instrumental specifications of the XF multi-well system are missing
Comparison with low-resolution instruments
Low-resolution instruments (compare HRR) with Clark-type polarographic oxygen sensors were used for validation of data obtained with the XF.
